A red flag doesn't stop being a red flag just because someone wraps it in spiritual language. In fact, some of the most dangerous dating behaviors in Christian circles come disguised as spiritual maturity. Here are the warning signs you need to know before your next relationship.
Why Are Red Flags Harder to Spot in Christian Dating?
On the Let's Talk About It podcast, Daniel and Elles Maddry read through dozens of real Christian dating stories submitted by their audience. The pattern was striking: many of the worst experiences involved people using faith as a tool for control, pressure, or manipulation. The spiritual language made it harder for the other person to push back because questioning someone's "word from God" can feel like questioning God himself.
That's exactly why these red flags are so dangerous. In a secular context, if someone said "I had a dream that we're supposed to be together" after one date, you'd run. But in Christian spaces, we've been conditioned to take spiritual language seriously, and some people exploit that. Knowing the difference between genuine spiritual conviction and spiritual manipulation is a skill every Christian dater needs.
Red Flag #1: They Claim God Told Them You're "The One" Way Too Early
One of the stories on the podcast involved a man who, after two dates, told a woman that God told him to move from California to Arizona specifically to be with her. He'd been living with another woman just two weeks before. He wrote letters to her pastor, showed up at her workplace, and left notes on her car about how she'd be a great mom to "their children." Her pastor eventually had to intervene.
The pastor's words were clarifying: "It can't be God's plan if she's not a willing participant." That line should be written on every Christian dating guide in existence. God does not override someone's consent to fulfill a relationship. If someone claims divine direction for your relationship but you don't feel the same way, that's not you resisting God. That's them misusing his name.
This doesn't mean God never speaks about relationships. But genuine leading from the Holy Spirit comes with peace, patience, and respect for the other person's agency. It doesn't come with pressure, urgency, or the expectation that you fall in line because they had a dream.
Red Flag #2: They Use Scripture to Manipulate or Control
Another story involved a man who, after being broken up with, threatened to bring it before the church "Matthew 18 style," claiming the breakup was sin. Daniel's one-word response: manipulation. Matthew 18 is about confronting a brother or sister in genuine sin, not about forcing someone to stay in a relationship they've chosen to leave.
Similarly, one man told a woman he wasn't interested by comparing himself to Jesus and saying she wasn't in his "inner circle of disciples." Using Jesus as your breakup script is not spiritual maturity. It's weaponizing faith to avoid a normal human conversation.
Watch for anyone who reaches for a Bible verse to justify controlling behavior. Scripture is meant to guide, convict, and encourage. It is not meant to be a tool for emotional manipulation in dating.
Red Flag #3: They Never Ask You Questions
One submission described a date at Cracker Barrel where the man talked for two straight hours about his calling to Africa without asking a single question. No curiosity about her life, her interests, her faith, or her goals. She didn't speak the entire time. Afterwards, he said their callings didn't align.
Here's what should be obvious: people enjoy conversations where they're asked thoughtful questions. A great first date involves a balance of sharing and asking. If someone talks for two hours without coming up for air, that's not confidence. That's self-absorption. And if they end the date by saying your callings don't align after never bothering to learn what your calling is, they were never interested in you as a person. They were looking for an audience.
Red Flag #4: Explosive Emotional Reactions
The last story on the episode involved a man who had a crush on a woman in his small group for a year and a half but never said a word. The moment another man showed interest in her, he had an angry outburst in front of the group, shouting "I've known her for a year and a half!" Then he went on to marry someone else as if nothing happened.
Let's call it what it is: a rage flag. Someone who won't use their words until they're raging is showing you their internal world. That kind of possessiveness, treating a person as "claimed" without ever pursuing a relationship, reveals a pattern of entitlement and poor emotional regulation. If someone can go a year and a half without communicating interest and then explodes when someone else does, that's not passion. That's a warning sign.
What Are the Green Flags to Look For Instead?
The podcast also highlighted a genuinely healthy story. A woman accidentally texted her date (instead of her mom) that the date wasn't going well. His response? Grace. He let her delete the text, laughed it off, and continued the date. They're now married.
Green flags look like emotional maturity under pressure, the ability to handle awkward moments with grace, honesty, curiosity about the other person, and a willingness to communicate. They're not flashy. They don't make for dramatic stories. But they're the foundation of every healthy relationship.
Every week, we break down the conversations the church avoids.
Get them straight to your inbox.
Watch/Listen to the Full Episode
YouTube: Watch on YouTube
Spotify: Listen on Spotify
Apple Podcasts: Listen on Apple
Related Reading
- When Someone Uses God to Pressure You Into a Relationship
- Signs of a Controlling Partner in Christian Dating
- Are Popular Dating Theories Biblical? 6 Theories Tested
- How to Know If You Should Call Off Your Engagement
Frequently Asked Questions
What are red flags in Christian dating?
Common red flags in Christian dating include someone claiming God told them you're meant to be together very early on, using Scripture to control or manipulate your decisions, refusing to respect your boundaries, explosive emotional reactions, and a consistent pattern of talking about themselves without showing genuine interest in you. Any behavior that uses spiritual language to pressure, guilt, or control you is a red flag, no matter how "godly" it sounds on the surface.
How do I know if someone is spiritually manipulating me?
Spiritual manipulation in dating looks like using God's name to pressure you into decisions you're not comfortable with. If someone says "God told me" and your only options are to agree or feel like you're disobeying God, that's manipulation. Genuine spiritual leading comes with peace, patience, and respect for your free will. If someone's "word from God" conveniently benefits them and pressures you, question it. A good pastor or mentor can help you discern the difference.
What are green flags to look for when dating as a Christian?
Green flags include emotional maturity under pressure, genuine curiosity about your life and faith, the ability to handle awkward moments with grace, honest and clear communication, and respect for your boundaries without requiring a spiritual justification. Look for someone who asks questions, listens well, and responds to conflict with humility rather than anger or manipulation. The best partners are the ones who feel safe to be yourself around.
