"God told me we're supposed to be together" is not a conversation starter. It's a pressure tactic. If someone's "word from the Lord" about your relationship doesn't leave room for your own discernment, free will, or a simple no, something is very wrong. Here's how to recognize it and respond.
What Does Spiritual Pressure in Dating Look Like?
On the Let's Talk About It podcast, Daniel and Elles Maddry read a story from a listener that paints a textbook picture of spiritual pressure in dating. A woman went on two dates with a man who had just moved from California after leaving a woman he'd been living with. After learning she was a virgin, he became "strangely fixated" and said, "This is just more proof that God told me to leave California to be with you."
It escalated from there. He wrote letters to her pastor. He showed up at her church during the week to talk about her. He sat in the parking lot at her job, leaving notes on her windshield about how watching her with customers proved she'd be a great mother to "their children." When she tried to end things, he wouldn't accept it. It took her pastor stepping in multiple times to make it stop.
This is an extreme case, but the root dynamic is common. Someone uses God's name to claim a relationship that the other person hasn't agreed to. And because it's framed as spiritual, the person on the receiving end feels confused, guilty, or afraid to push back. After all, how do you say no to something God supposedly said?
It Can't Be God's Plan If You're Not a Willing Participant
The pastor in that story said something that should be a baseline rule for every Christian: "It can't be God's plan if she's not a willing participant." That sentence dismantles the entire framework of spiritual pressure in dating.
God created you with free will. He doesn't override consent to make a relationship happen. He doesn't force someone into a covenant they haven't chosen. And he certainly doesn't give one person a divine mandate that requires the other person to comply. If God is truly leading two people together, both people will have peace about it. Not pressure. Not confusion. Not fear.
Another story from the episode: a pastor publicly announced that a couple was engaged during a church service. They were not engaged. He called it a prophecy. Elles' response was firm: at their church, they don't prophesy dates, mates or babies. And that's a wise boundary. Prophetic words about someone's romantic future, especially unsolicited ones, can be deeply damaging when they're wrong, and they create enormous pressure to make something happen that God may not be directing at all.
How to Respond When Someone Claims God Told Them About Your Relationship
First, you are allowed to say no. A "word from God" that someone gives you about your relationship does not obligate you to comply. You have your own relationship with the Holy Spirit. You have your own discernment. If what someone is saying doesn't line up with what you're sensing from the Lord, trust that. You are not being disobedient by declining someone's romantic advances, no matter how spiritual the packaging.
Second, bring it into community. Don't process this alone. Talk to a trusted pastor, mentor, or friend who knows you well. Ask them to help you evaluate whether this feels like genuine leading from God or spiritual manipulation. An outside perspective can cut through the fog quickly.
Third, set clear boundaries and enforce them. If someone won't accept your no, that's not persistence. That's a violation of your agency. You don't owe anyone a relationship because they claim God said so. And if they can't respect your boundary, involve a pastor or leader who can intervene, just like the story from the podcast.
How Does God Actually Lead in Relationships?
God's leading is marked by peace (Colossians 3:15), patience (1 Corinthians 13:4), and mutual confirmation. If God is directing two people toward each other, both of them will sense it. There won't be a need for one person to convince, pressure, or spiritually strong-arm the other into agreement.
God also leads through wisdom, community, and the fruit of someone's life. A man who was living with another woman two weeks ago and now claims God told him to move across the country for you does not have the fruit of a well-ordered life. Claims of divine direction should be tested against the person's character, their track record, and the counsel of people who know them.
God does speak about relationships. He does lead. He does direct. But his leading never overrides your will, never pressures you into fear, and never requires you to abandon your own discernment. If something feels off, it probably is. Trust that instinct. It might be the Holy Spirit protecting you.
Every week, we break down the conversations the church avoids.
Get them straight to your inbox.
Watch/Listen to the Full Episode
YouTube: Watch on YouTube
Spotify: Listen on Spotify
Apple Podcasts: Listen on Apple
Related Reading
- Christian Dating Red Flags You Shouldn't Ignore
- Are Soul Ties Real? What the Bible Actually Says
- The Soulmate Myth: Why 'The One' Isn't Biblical
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do if someone says God told them to date me?
You are not obligated to agree. You have your own discernment and your own relationship with the Holy Spirit. If what they're saying doesn't resonate with what you're sensing from God, trust that. Bring the situation to a trusted pastor or mentor for an outside perspective. And if the person won't accept your answer, set firm boundaries and involve a leader if needed. God's genuine leading never overrides your free will or requires you to feel pressured.
Can God really tell someone who to marry?
God can and does lead people in relationships. But his leading is characterized by peace, patience, mutual confirmation, and alignment with Scripture. It's not characterized by pressure, urgency, or one-sided declarations. If God is genuinely bringing two people together, both of them will sense it in their own time. Be wary of anyone who claims divine direction that conveniently pressures you into something you haven't agreed to.
How do I set boundaries with someone who uses spiritual language to control me?
Be direct and clear: "I appreciate that you feel God has spoken to you, but I don't feel the same way, and I need you to respect that." If they continue to press, involve a pastor or trusted leader. Healthy spiritual community will support your right to make your own decisions. You do not have to argue theology or prove that God didn't say what they claim. You are allowed to simply say no. A person who can't respect that answer is showing you exactly why the answer should be no.
